478 - BR03_POST2305109_Satterfield,_Joshua_Attachment_A_Redacted_Termination_Letter.pdf
About this document
- Layer
- packet: an item in a POST meeting packet
- Type as titled
- case_attachment (kind from title)
- File
- 07efb9359c89127fbc927796e43f3756bbcc63a4 application/pdf
- Cases
About: Joshua Satterfield (case)
Joshua Satterfield
September 22, 2022
Page 12 of 14
VI. EMPLOYEE'S RESPONSE AND ADMINISTRATIVE CONFERENCE CHAIR ASSESSMENT
An in person administrative conference was held on this matter on August 24, 2022. You, your attorney, Tom Yu of the Law Offices of Pelayes and Yu, APC, Police Chief Jeremiah Hart, Lt. Charles Fisher, and Senior Human Resources Analyst Robert Weinmeister, were all in attendance. At the administrative conference, I offered both you and your attorney an opportunity to provide me with additional information to consider before making my decision. Your attorney stated that he would be presenting on your behalf.
While your attorney made various arguments, his comments focused primarily on the warrant that was associated with the origin of the text messages that he claimed were "...ill gotten evidence" and he alleged that the Police Chief and the Torrance Police Department violated the California Electronic Communications Privacy Act. However, my understanding is that all of the arguments raised by Mr. Yu were set forth in a Motion to Suppress which was recently denied in its entirety by the Court. A true and correct copy of the Judge's Memorandum of Decision is attached hereto as Attachment A and incorporated by reference herein. In summary, the Court found that Penal Code section 1546.4 does not require suppression of the evidence in this matter, that the search warrant at issue did not violate section 1546.1(d)(1), that the Department's pending administrative investigation does not violate section 1546.1(d)(2), and that the City did not violate Judge Carter's order by reviewing Petitioners' messages or providing the messages to the DA's office. The Court also ruled that Attorney Corey Glave was not entitled to the return of his attorney-client communications which were captured in the search warrant data.5 Irrespective of Mr. Yu's arguments regarding the source of the text messages, the evidence demonstrates that you violated numerous Department policies, as outlined above and your misconduct cannot be excused. Any future appeals of the Motion to Suppress would not change my determinations regarding your misconduct contained within.
In response to the violation of the City's Anti-Harassment Policy (Policy 34), Mr. Yu contended that there was no victim and that no one was offended by the associated texts. Additionally, your attorney stated that "...everyone has a bias." As defined in Policy 34, the content of the cited text messages for which this discipline is recommended are clearly related to protected classifications (Section 34.10a), they represent visual and/or written harassment (Section 34.10d) that was circulated amongst police officers that were not reported to a supervisor, manager or to the Human Resources Division (Section 134.05) or to their immediate supervisor or appropriate authority figure (Section 134.15). It is documented that you completed requisite Anti-Harassment Training and signed acknowledgment of both City and Department Policies. Biases that may or may not exist in the greater society are no excuse for the violation of these standards put into place to promote a hostile free work environment and unbiased approach to a police officer's interaction with the public you swore to serve and protect. However, my understanding is that all of the arguments raised by Mr. Yu were set forth in a Motion to Suppress which was recently denied in its entirety by the Court.
5 It should be noted that the Administrative Conference Chair did not rely upon any attorney-client privileged communications in making the decision to terminate Satterfield's employment.
3031 Torrance Boulevard • Torrance, California 90503 • Telephone 310/618-5880 • Fax 310/618-5891
Visit Torrance's home page: <http://www.TorranceCA.Gov>
590
Keys: ← → or j k turn pages; / finds.