Documents › 0715a4d3e4f2d66976fb22536a30dd52e1e8645d:1-43

Enea Joshua Accusation and Order

Certification Actions commission decisionboard proceeding 43 pages (file pages 1–43) original file
About this document
Layer
cert order: part of a file an agency produced
Type as titled
accusation and order (kind from doc_type)
Produced as
https://post.ca.gov/Portals/0/post_docs/Certification_Actions/Module/Enea_Joshua_Accusation_and_Order.pdf
File
0715a4d3e4f2d66976fb22536a30dd52e1e8645d application/pdf
Cases
POST 2307454 · ENEA, JOSHUA PAUL (case number)

About: ENEA, JOSHUA PAUL (case)

Page 40 · file page 40 larger image
Image of page 40; its text is alongside
Text: OCR

LEGAL CONCLUSIONS

Burden and Standard of Proof

  1. Complainant is required to prove cause for cancellation of respondent's certificates, which are essentially licenses. The parties disagree regarding the standard of proof.

  2. Respondent initially argued that section 13510.85, subdivision (a)(5), specifies clear and convincing evidence as the standard of proof in this proceeding.

  3. Section 13510.85 relates to "serious misconduct" investigations. Subdivisions (a)(4) & (5) specify that the board shall use the clear and convincing evidence as the standard of proof for recommendations of revocation of a certificate, and that the commission shall use the clear and convincing evidence as the standard of proof for decisions to adopt such recommendations. Notably, in subdivision (a)(6), the Legislature provided for a formal hearing before an administrative law judge, but did not specify a standard of proof.

  4. Complainant correctly pointed out that this proceeding is not a "serious misconduct" proceeding to revoke respondent's certificates, and does not arise under section 13510.85. Rather, this is a proceeding to cancel respondent's certificates under section 13510.8, subdivision (a)(3), and California Code of Regulations, title 11, section 1202, subdivision (e)(1)(A). (See Legal Conclusions 8 & 9.) Section 13510.8 does not specify a standard of proof. Complainant cited Evidence Code section 115 for the proposition that "Except as otherwise provided by law, the burden of proof requires proof by a preponderance of the evidence." Complainant also argued that, pursuant to the statutory interpretive principle expressio unius est exclusio alterius (expression of

31

Keys: ← → or j k turn pages; / finds.