Enea Joshua Accusation and Order
About this document
- Layer
- cert order: part of a file an agency produced
- Type as titled
- accusation and order (kind from doc_type)
- Produced as
- https://post.ca.gov/Portals/0/post_docs/Certification_Actions/Module/Enea_Joshua_Accusation_and_Order.pdf
- File
- 0715a4d3e4f2d66976fb22536a30dd52e1e8645d application/pdf
- Cases
About: ENEA, JOSHUA PAUL (case)
LEGAL CONCLUSIONS
Burden and Standard of Proof
-
Complainant is required to prove cause for cancellation of respondent's certificates, which are essentially licenses. The parties disagree regarding the standard of proof.
-
Respondent initially argued that section 13510.85, subdivision (a)(5), specifies clear and convincing evidence as the standard of proof in this proceeding.
-
Section 13510.85 relates to "serious misconduct" investigations. Subdivisions (a)(4) & (5) specify that the board shall use the clear and convincing evidence as the standard of proof for recommendations of revocation of a certificate, and that the commission shall use the clear and convincing evidence as the standard of proof for decisions to adopt such recommendations. Notably, in subdivision (a)(6), the Legislature provided for a formal hearing before an administrative law judge, but did not specify a standard of proof.
-
Complainant correctly pointed out that this proceeding is not a "serious misconduct" proceeding to revoke respondent's certificates, and does not arise under section 13510.85. Rather, this is a proceeding to cancel respondent's certificates under section 13510.8, subdivision (a)(3), and California Code of Regulations, title 11, section 1202, subdivision (e)(1)(A). (See Legal Conclusions 8 & 9.) Section 13510.8 does not specify a standard of proof. Complainant cited Evidence Code section 115 for the proposition that "Except as otherwise provided by law, the burden of proof requires proof by a preponderance of the evidence." Complainant also argued that, pursuant to the statutory interpretive principle expressio unius est exclusio alterius (expression of
31
Keys: ← → or j k turn pages; / finds.