Enea Joshua Accusation and Order
About this document
- Layer
- cert order: part of a file an agency produced
- Type as titled
- accusation and order (kind from doc_type)
- Produced as
- https://post.ca.gov/Portals/0/post_docs/Certification_Actions/Module/Enea_Joshua_Accusation_and_Order.pdf
- File
- 0715a4d3e4f2d66976fb22536a30dd52e1e8645d application/pdf
- Cases
About: ENEA, JOSHUA PAUL (case)
respondent is correct to the extent that the evidence does not show that it is certain that the "original" or associated Angeli images or the two images described in Factual Finding 50 were ever stored on his Brown Hard Drive. However, considering the totality of the evidence, it is more likely than not that these four "original" or associated CSAM images were stored on respondent's Brown Hard Drive at the time it was seized in 2017.
-
Pursuant to Heaton's unrebuted testimony and other evidence, the Ukrainian images and videos found on Respondent's Brown Hard Drive were CSAM and most of them were not thumbs.db files, but rather the "original" or associated CSAM images and videos.
-
It appears that Beauchamp and complainant at least initially believed that the numerous "create dates" and "modified dates" earlier in time than March 27, 2007, proved to a certainty that these CSAM files were stored on respondent's Brown Hard Drive prior to March 27, 2007. The evidence shows that these "create dates" and "modified dates" are probative but not by themselves reliable indicators of when a file is stored on a particular device, pursuant to the unrebuted expert opinions of Rodriguez and Heaton.
-
However, the evidence shows that: respondent owned and regularly used the Brown Hard Drive prior to March 27, 2007, apparently years prior. Four CSAM files were stored on the device at the time it was seized in 2017, and a dozen other CSAM files very likely had been stored on the device but later deleted, as shown by the existence of the related thumbs.db files. Respondent surreptitiously photographed minor females in bathing suits without their consent at a water park in 2006 and/or 2007 and surreptitiously photographed a minor female in a yogurt shop in 2012, as well as his neighbor through a hole in her fence in 2017. On five occasions in 2015 and
29
Keys: ← → or j k turn pages; / finds.