Enea Joshua Accusation and Order
About this document
- Layer
- cert order: part of a file an agency produced
- Type as titled
- accusation and order (kind from doc_type)
- Produced as
- https://post.ca.gov/Portals/0/post_docs/Certification_Actions/Module/Enea_Joshua_Accusation_and_Order.pdf
- File
- 0715a4d3e4f2d66976fb22536a30dd52e1e8645d application/pdf
- Cases
About: ENEA, JOSHUA PAUL (case)
they depict scantily clad, prepubescent children in "sexually explicit or coy" poses, with breasts or nipples sometimes exposed, and the images focus on the subjects' genitalia.
-
Beauchamp also observed that two other image files on the Brown Hard Drive depicted what appeared to be minor females with no secondary sexual characteristics. One image shows a female's legs spread apart, and the image is focused on her naked groin. The other image depicts an erect penis outside a vaginal opening, with what appears to be ejaculate on the female's vagina and leg. Beauchamp reports that this female had no pubic hair and appeared to be either very petite or a minor. However, these files were not confirmed to match known images of CSAM. Each of these electronic files was a thumbs.db file.
-
In testimony in a preliminary hearing in respondent's criminal matter, Rodriguez explained that, if the thumbs.db files were transferred onto respondent's device without the original images, the person who received the thumbs.db files might never have known that the original files existed. Rodriguez used forensic tools to extract the images from the thumbs.db files found on the Seized Devices. He explained that the average computer user would not be able to see the image from a thumbs.db file if the original image was deleted or never existed on the device. He opined that a thumbs.db file is an indicator of what image might have been on a device, but conceded that to determine whether or not a user knowingly possessed the image, it "would probably be better to have the original file." Rodriguez explained that he could not make a determination whether the original images were ever on any of respondent's devices.
-
Rodriguez also explained that the "create date" of an electronic image file generally shows when the file was created, but does not mean that it was created on that date on the device upon which it is found. The evidence at hearing established
19
Keys: ← → or j k turn pages; / finds.