Documents › 03d5ce0e699e63498d4b82aafa8515c9d8b860b7:1-37

Law Office of Todd Simonson Investigative Report IA 22-07 (Officer Paul Matejcek)

POST board investigation reportagency investigation 2022-06-29 37 pages (file pages 1–37) original file
About this document
Layer
attachment: a document a meeting packet links to
Type as titled
ia investigative report (kind from doc_type)
File
03d5ce0e699e63498d4b82aafa8515c9d8b860b7 application/pdf
Cases
POST 2300017 · Paul Matejcek (filed under case)

About: Paul Matejcek (case)

Page 36 · file page 36 larger image
Image of page 36; its text is alongside
Text: OCR

Finally, Officer Matejcek's contentions that his kick of Ms. V1 was justified by police academy training he received, and that BPD Officer O2 O2 had been exonerated for kicking a suspect in the head, were substantially rebutted by the evidence. For one, the three "Learning Domain" pages from Officer Matejcek's police academy workbooks that Officer Matejcek provided as support for the idea that kicking an actively resisting suspect in the midsection was proper, did not include any mention of kicking a handcuffed suspect and Officer Matejcek conceded that none of his police academy kick training involved hypothetical situations of kicking a handcuffed suspect.33 Sergeant Nance stated that BPD training records show Officer Matejcek is currently up to date with all perishable skills training and emphatically added that the BPD "never trained to strike a handcuffed suspect" in any of the BPD courses—including the perishable skills trainings involving use of force, arrest and control, and defensive tactics. Sergeant Nance also opined that only in a "very, very unusual circumstance" might striking a handcuffed suspect be deemed as reasonable, such as a handcuffed suspect reaching for a weapon such as a firearm, or about to run into traffic.

Relatedly, a review of Officer O2 May 17, 2017, police report34 shows that Officer O2 was involved in one of those "very unusual circumstances." According to the report, Officer O2 assisted with the apprehension of a suspect wanted for stalking in Emeryville who had engaged Emeryville PD and California Highway Patrol units in a vehicle pursuit to the suspect's home in Brentwood. Officer O2 was one of three officers who apprehended the suspect in the suspect's garage. The suspect struggled with the three officers and refused to comply with repeated commands to place his hands behind his back. Officer O2 wrote that he kicked the unhandcuffed suspect on the left side of the face and back of the head believing the suspect's actions presented an "imminent danger" to the officers if he continued to reach for a possible weapon in his waistband area.

Based on all of the foregoing evidence, and consideration of the relevant "factors used to determine reasonableness of force" referenced in section BPD Policy Manual section 300.3.2, there is sufficient evidence to find that Officer Matejcek used unreasonable force on April 23, 2022, by kicking Ms. V1 with substantial force to her left torso area with his right foot while Ms. V1 was handcuffed and effectively surrounded by three officers, because Ms. V1 stood up contrary to commands to remain seated. Officer Matejcek's level of force against Ms. V1 was "not proportional to the seriousness of the suspected offense or the reasonably perceived level of actual or threatened resistance" and, therefore, violated the BPD Use of Force policy.


punt her through the shed," it appears that Officer Matejcek's leg was nearly fully extended at the point his foot made contact with Ms. V1 torso. Nevertheless, under the circumstances here, even a somewhat restrained kick was not reasonable.

33 Exhibit 9.

34 Exhibit 13 at p. 16.

Confidential Report
City of Brentwood

34

Keys: ← → or j k turn pages; / finds.