Law Office of Todd Simonson Investigative Report IA 22-07 (Officer Paul Matejcek)
About this document
- Layer
- attachment: a document a meeting packet links to
- Type as titled
- ia investigative report (kind from doc_type)
- File
- 03d5ce0e699e63498d4b82aafa8515c9d8b860b7 application/pdf
- Cases
About: Paul Matejcek (case)
on the camera in Officer Franson's car than it had been for most of the contact.24 At the minute 9:08 mark on Officer Franson's body-worn camera video, Ms. [V1] can be seen leaning forward in an attempt to stand up despite Officer Matejcek reporting that he told Ms. [V1] to "stay seated" and "sit down" (which cannot be heard on Officer Franson's vehicle camera video, but was attested to by Officer Flynn). Officer Matejcek then took his first of three quick steps toward Ms. [V1] from about six feet away as she began to stand up, then kicked Ms. [V1] hard with his right foot to her left torso area. Officer Matejcek's kick connected with Ms. [V1] left side just as Ms. [V1] appeared to stand up completely, and with enough force to send Ms. [V1] sprawling backwards into the open shed door before falling to the ground on her buttocks. As captured on Officer Franson's vehicle camera, Officer Matejcek's kick of Ms. [V1] sounded as if it caused Ms. [V1] to yell "aah" and created an audible "thud" as her body struck the open shed door behind her.25
At the time Officer Matejcek kicked Ms. [V1] she did not present any immediate threat to Officers Matejcek, Franson, or Flynn, or any other citizen.26 While she had yelled at officers and started to stand up contrary to the commands by Officer Matejcek to "sit down," Ms. [V1] made no movement toward Officer Matejcek or the other two officers indicating physical resistance, made no movement indicating an attempt to run away, and made no attempt to spit at the officers.27 At the moment Officer Matejcek started his approach toward Ms. [V1] then kicked her with considerable force, Ms. [V1] did not present any reasonably foreseeable potential of injury to the three officers or any other person, did not present a reasonably foreseeable risk of escape, and there was no apparent need for "immediate control" of Ms. [V1] or "a prompt resolution of the situation."28 To the contrary, Ms. [V1] was impaired by alcohol, handcuffed, effectively surrounded by three larger officers, and was in the middle of a large, otherwise empty, parking lot. Despite Officer Matejcek's stated concerns about the risk of Ms. [V1] "running away or being able to slip her handcuffed arms from behind her" if she stood up, Ms. [V1] did not attempt to do either before Officer Matejcek kicked her. Had Ms. [V1] intended to fight or run from officers, she was at a profound disadvantage in every sense, and could have been subdued without much effort using less intrusive means, just as Officer Matejcek had demonstrated when he initially detained Ms. [V1].
Officer Matejcek's assertions that he used the kick to create distance from Ms. [V1] to avoid being spit on is unpersuasive and contradicted by his actions. Ms. [V1] had neither spit nor attempted to spit on Officers Matejcek, Flynn, or Franson before Officer Matejcek kicked her. Moreover, Officer Matejcek made no effort during the several minutes before the kick, or
24 Exhibit 2, 8:30-8:55.
25 Exhibit 1, 9:07-9:12; Exhibit 2, 8:50-8:54.
26 Exhibit 15, Section 300.3.2(a).
27 Exhibit 15, Section 300.3.2 (n).
28 Exhibit 15, Section 300.3.2 (m), (o), (p).
Confidential Report
City of Brentwood
32
Keys: ← → or j k turn pages; / finds.