Law Office of Todd Simonson Investigative Report IA 22-07 (Officer Paul Matejcek)
About this document
- Layer
- attachment: a document a meeting packet links to
- Type as titled
- ia investigative report (kind from doc_type)
- File
- 03d5ce0e699e63498d4b82aafa8515c9d8b860b7 application/pdf
- Cases
About: Paul Matejcek (case)
In addition to BPD training, Sergeant Nance has conducted numerous trainings for outside agencies as well—including training he developed for the California Commission on Peace Officer Standards and Training (“POST”)—in the areas of defensive tactics, arrest and control tactics, and firearms. Sergeant Nance was the defensive tactics columnist for Officer.com and for LawOfficer.com for several years, and is currently on the editorial advisory board for Officer Magazine. He has contributed articles regarding defensive and arrest and control tactics to Police magazine, CATOnews (California Association of Tactical Officers), and several firearm industry publications intended primarily for private citizens.12
Sergeant Nance stated that he reviewed Officer Matejcek’s report about the incident, as well as Officer Franson’s body-worn camera video, prior to his interview with the Investigator.
2. Officer Matejcek’s Training
Sergeant Nance has worked around Officer Matejcek “off and on” since Officer Matejcek was hired in 2017. Sergeant Nance did not recall being present at any use-of-force by Officer Matejcek and has not rendered any opinions about any prior use-of-force by Officer Matejcek. Sergeant Nance stated that he did not have any prior negative history with Officer Matejcek.
Sergeant Nance agreed with the three pages of Learning Domain literature provided by Officer Matejcek from Officer Matejcek’s police academy workbooks; that is, in cases where an unhandcuffed suspect was actively resisting, an officer’s use of the foot as an impact weapon to a suspect’s midsection could be reasonable depending on the circumstances. Sergeant Nance noted that a BPD defensive tactics course taught in April 2018 specifically addressed kicking as part of a segment that reviewed “striking and personal body weapons to include viable possible techniques, development of power, and use of striking to facilitate movement or disengage with a suspect.” The most recent BPD use-of-force training in April 2022 was an introduction to “Gracie Survival Tactics”—involving takedowns, clenches, and “ground control” when wrestling with a suspect—policy review, and de-escalation techniques.
Sergeant Nance also stated “. . . we’ve never trained to strike a handcuffed suspect” in any of the BPD courses—including the use-of-force, arrest and control, and defensive tactics trainings that officers are regularly required to complete as renewal of “perishable skills.” When asked if there were circumstances he was aware of where kicking or otherwise striking a handcuffed suspect would be reasonable, Sergeant Nance stated that he had not been personally involved in such a situation but believed that in a “very, very unusual circumstance”—like if a handcuffed suspect reached for a weapon such as a firearm, or was about to run into traffic—that striking the handcuffed suspect might be deemed as reasonable.
Sergeant Nance stated that BPD records show that Officer Matejcek is currently up to date with perishable skills training and that Officer Matejcek took other relevant training, outside
12 See, e.g., LinkedIn (<https://www.linkedin.com/in/richard-nance-a1759017/>), Officer.com (<https://www.officer.com/home/contact/10234412/richard-nance>), Officer Magazine editorial advisory board (<https://www.officer.com/command-hq/article/21263337/introducing-the-officer-media-group-editorial-advisory-board>); Police magazine (<https://www.policemag.com/339931/cuffing-with-useful-force>).
Confidential Report
City of Brentwood
25
Keys: ← → or j k turn pages; / finds.